Hotels in Shelter Island (New York State, USA)

269 hotels in Shelter Island

  1. The Chequit

    3 Stars
    On-site dining with harbor views
    Select dates to see exact prices
  2. The Pridwin Hotel

    4 Stars
    On-site dining and weekly barbecue
    See prices from 3 sites
    from€346
  3. American Beech Hotel

    4 Stars
    On-Site Dining and Bars
    Select dates to see exact prices
  4. Sunset Beach

    2 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices
  5. House on Chase Creek

    Walk to North Ferry and restaurants
    Select dates to see exact prices
  6. Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island

    Heated pool and evening firepit
    Select dates to see exact prices
  7. Cottage Fields Of Lavender By The Sea 5min Greenport Shelter Island

    Select dates to see exact prices
  8. Seven on Shelter Island

    4 Stars
    Select dates to see exact prices
  9. One Bedroom Duplex Farmhouse

    Select dates to see exact prices
  10. Waterfront Charmer On Idyllic Shelter Island For Summer Rental

    Select dates to see exact prices
  11. Shelter Island Waterfront Home

    Select dates to see exact prices
  12. Shelter Island, Ny Fully Renovated Farmhouse With Heated Pool

    Select dates to see exact prices
  13. Summer Beach Paradise

    Select dates to see exact prices
  14. 3 Story Contemporary

    Select dates to see exact prices
  15. Mint Condition Water Mill South Of The Highway With Mecox Bay Access

    Select dates to see exact prices
  16. Unbelievable Water Views, 50 Heated Pool And Private Beach

    Select dates to see exact prices
  17. Beautiful Shelter Island Getaway On Over An Acre, Minutes From The Ferry!

    Select dates to see exact prices
  18. Greenport Village On The Bay

    Select dates to see exact prices
  19. Tranquil 3br Shelter Island Beach House With Private Beach Access

    Select dates to see exact prices
  20. Beautiful Shelter Island/hamptons Beach House Monthly Rental

    Select dates to see exact prices
  21. Sun-filled, Custom-designed 5-bedroom House In Sag Harbor W/ Heated Pool And Spa

    Select dates to see exact prices
  22. Luxurious Brand New Home Steps From Beach, Pool And Family-friendly Amenities!

    Select dates to see exact prices
  23. Aia Award Winning Country Estate In Tranquil Shelter Island

    Select dates to see exact prices
  24. Summer In Style On Shelter Island - Modern House Only Available All Season

    Select dates to see exact prices
  25. The Greenport Beach Cottage: 3 Min Walk To Beach, 3 Min Drive To Town

    Select dates to see exact prices
  26. Waterfront Retreat With Heated Pool, Spa & Seasonal Water Sports

    Select dates to see exact prices
  27. Chic Coastal Farmhouse With Private Pool, Steps From The Water Your...

    Select dates to see exact prices
  28. Breathtaking Waterfront 5-bedroom House In Charming Shelter Island With Pool

    Select dates to see exact prices
  29. Sandpoint by Rove Travel - 6BR Family Home with Pool

    Select dates to see exact prices
  30. Chic Shelter Island A-Frame with Private Pool, Stylish Interiors, and...

    Select dates to see exact prices
  31. Shelter Island Spacious Getaway with Cozy Fireplace

    Select dates to see exact prices
  32. 4-bedroom House On Lake In Delightful Shelter Island With Wifi, Ac On 3.2 Acres

    Select dates to see exact prices
  33. The Owls Nest

    Select dates to see exact prices
  34. Modern, Great Sleeping, Walk To Town And Beach. 2-bedroom Condo In Greenport

    Select dates to see exact prices
  35. Steps to Beach + Sunset Views! East Marion Home

    Select dates to see exact prices

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Popular hotel categories in Shelter Island

Frequently Asked Questions about Shelter Island

Hotels in Shelter Island

You may also be interested in these hotels...

Points of Interest - Shelter Island

Top Destinations

More Top Destinations