4 Stars
Select dates to see exact prices
Select dates to see exact prices
  • reception
  • bedroom

1 / 64

Good to know

  • On-Site Dining and Bars

    Dine at the property's farm-to-table American restaurant or enjoy craft cocktails at the Black Llama bar located within the courtyard.

  • Central Greenport Village Location

    Walk to local shops, restaurants, and the harbor within minutes from this centrally located property.

  • Limited Accessibility and Stairs

    The property consists of multiple small buildings without elevators, requiring guests to navigate steep staircases to reach some rooms.

  • Pet-Friendly Boutique Accommodations

    Bring your dog along to this boutique hotel, which provides specific amenities for pets and welcomes well-behaved animals.

  • Picnic Basket Breakfast Delivery

    Receive a complimentary continental breakfast delivered directly to your room door each morning in a picnic basket.

  • Potential Noise From Courtyard

    Guest rooms located near the on-site restaurant and bar may experience noise from music and dining activity during evening hours.

This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.

Rooms

  • Deluxe Apartment, 2 Bedrooms, Private Bathroom

    • 1 2 King Beds
    • Sleeps 4
    • 441 sq ft
  • Deluxe Suite, 1 King Bed

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • 400 sq ft
  • Suite, 1 King Bed (#1)

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • 400 sq ft
  • Standard Room, 1 King Bed

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • 400 sq ft

Compare with similar stays

Selected stay

4 Stars

  • WiFi
  • Pets
  • A/C
Select dates to see exact prices

Similar stays

  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Spa
    See prices from 5 sites
    from€346
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Spa
    See prices from 5 sites
    from€353
  • 4 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Parking
    • Pets
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    See prices from 9 sites
    from€216
  • 3 Stars

    • WiFi
    • Pool
    • Parking
    Select dates to see exact prices

Reviews

9.1
Excellent
based on 981 ratings from top 
sites
sites

Review summary

Summarized by AI from 500+ reviews

This hotel is a vibrant boutique retreat, perfect for couples, sightseers, and pet owners seeking a lively and engaging experience. Its prime location in the heart of Greenport village offers unparalleled access to numerous shops, bars, and restaurants, with the harbor just steps away. The full-service restaurant and Black Llama cocktail and raw bar provide an exceptional culinary journey, frequently praised for their amazing food and masterful drinks. Guests consistently commend the accommodating and friendly staff, who go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant stay. For a quieter experience, consider requesting a room not located directly above the bars.

Rated above average for Shelter Island

Guest reviews

Excellent70%
Very good9%
Good6%
Fair6%
Poor9%

Top amenities

  • WiFi
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar

All amenities

Property amenities

  • Express check-in/check-out
  • Pet friendly
  • Bar
  • Non-smoking rooms

Wellness

  • Massage
  • Dressing gown

Room amenities

  • Fireplace
  • Shower
  • Ironing board
  • Television

Sports facilities

  • Bike rental

Hotel characteristics

  • Family friendly

Location

302 Main St, Shelter Island, 11944, USA

Highlight

Central Greenport Village Location

Walk to local shops, restaurants, and the harbor within minutes from this centrally located property.

Distance from American Beech Hotel

  1. 0.6 km from Greenport
  2. 6.7 km from Shelter Island (City center)
  3. 7.2 km from Southold Historical Museum
  4. 12.9 km from Sag Harbor Whaling Museum
  5. 12.9 km from Custom House
  6. 19.2 km from Bridgehampton Historical Museum
  7. 21.6 km from Guild Hall
  8. 21.6 km from Mulford Farm Museum
  9. 21.7 km from Water Mill Museum
  10. 21.7 km from Water Mill Windmill
  11. 21.7 km from Home, Sweet Home Museum
  12. 96.6 km from Bradley International Airport

Property info

302 Main St, Shelter Island, 11944, USA

Frequently Asked Questions about American Beech Hotel

Is there a pool area at American Beech Hotel?

No, American Beech Hotel doesn’t offer pool areas.

Are pets allowed at American Beech Hotel?

Yes, American Beech Hotel has a pet policy that may vary based on the room type or availability. Please check with the hotel directly to learn about their pet policy.

Is parking available at American Beech Hotel?

No, American Beech Hotel doesn’t provide parking.

What time is check-in and check-out at American Beech Hotel?

Check-in at American Beech Hotel is available from: . Check-out time is by .

Where is American Beech Hotel located?

American Beech Hotel is located at 302 Main St, 11944, Shelter Island, USA.

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Among Top Rated Hotels in Shelter Island

  • 4 Stars
    Faraway Sag Harbor
    See prices from 5 sites
    from€353
  • 4 Stars
    The Shoals Suites & Slips
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 2 Stars
    Greenporter Hotel
    See prices from 8 sites
    from€190
  • 4 Stars
    The Menhaden
    See prices from 7 sites
    from€317
  • 3 Stars
    The Sagaponack
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 3 Stars
    EHP Resort & Marina
    Select dates to see exact prices
  • 5 Stars
    Topping Rose House
    See prices from 7 sites
    from€615

Other stays in Shelter Island

Popular hotel categories in Shelter Island

Destinations near American Beech Hotel